Living with persistent lower back pain can be physically and emotionally exhausting, especially after years of trying different treatments without lasting relief. This case study shares John Withy’s experience after living with chronic lower back pain for 27 years following a disc injury.

Read our complete guide to magnetic therapy for pain conditions

Learn about medical magnets for low back pain

How Can Lower Back Pain Persist for Decades?

In 1985, John injured his lower back while lifting and twisting, resulting in disc bulges at L3/4 and L5/S1.

Over the following years he consulted no fewer than 12 specialists and spent thousands of dollars on a wide range of treatments, including:

  • Physiotherapy
  • Chiropractic care
  • Acupuncture
  • Microwave therapy
  • Epidural injection

Despite these interventions, his pain continued.

As John explained:

“I have spent over 26 years on an average of 6/10 in pain and have taken pain medication daily for all this time.”

Understanding Persistent Lower Back Pain

Persistent lower back pain is often more complex than the original injury alone. Disc irritation, altered movement patterns, mechanical loading and changes within the nervous system may all contribute to ongoing symptoms.

This helps explain why people with apparently similar diagnoses can experience very different levels of pain and disability, and why recovery often requires an individualized approach.

Why Every Back Pain Case Is Different

Persistent lower back pain rarely has a single cause. Factors such as disc injuries, surrounding muscles, joint mechanics and nervous system sensitivity can all influence symptoms. Because of this, successful management often depends on selecting an appropriate treatment approach and applying it accurately rather than relying on a one-size-fits-all solution.

How Q Magnets Were Applied

After attending a National Pain Week seminar, John decided to trial Q Magnets despite initially being sceptical.

According to the original case report, Dianne Hermans applied:

This application reflects the Q Magnets Field | Dose | Placement (FDP) approach, where both magnet selection and anatomical placement are considered important variables.

Q Magnets are precision multipolar medical magnets designed to create localized static magnetic field environments. They are intended to complement appropriate clinical assessment and active rehabilitation rather than replace professional healthcare.

John’s Experience

John reported noticing an unusual sensation shortly after the magnets were applied.

However, the most significant change occurred the following morning.

He recalled:

“I could feel a strange sensation in my back almost immediately, but it wasn’t until the next day when I got out of bed. My wife said, ‘Look at you!’ For the first time in over 20 years I got straight out of bed with no pain.”

He continued:

“During the day I was able to get up from sitting with ease, again something I have been unable to do for decades.”

Two weeks later John reported:

“Two weeks later and my pain during the day is now about 1/10. To say that I am excited is an understatement. Thank you Q Magnets.”

John Withy
Manly, Queensland

Why Do Some People Respond Quickly While Others Do Not?

View Insight

Practical Takeaway

Not all lower back pain is the same. Disc injuries, nervous system sensitization, movement patterns and mechanical nerve compression may each contribute differently to symptoms.

Accurate diagnosis, individualized management and appropriate magnet placement remain important considerations when exploring Q Magnets as a complementary recovery support option.

Note from James Hermans

I personally met with John to authenticate his story. While his experience may seem remarkable to those unfamiliar with persistent disc-related pain, it is not an uncommon response in some individuals. There are also similar published case studies available in the Pediatric Neurology literature.

At the same time, it is important to recognize that outcomes vary. Some persistent pain cases, like John’s, respond quickly. Others may benefit most when Q Magnets are used alongside a supervised rehabilitation program, while some people may not respond to Q Magnets at all.

Long-term lower back pain remains a significant challenge worldwide. As a conservative, non-invasive option, Q Magnets may be worth considering before progressing to more invasive or long-term treatment approaches where appropriate.